Amazon tribe hits back at green 'colonialism'
      
   Juliette Jowit, environment editor   
   The Observer   
   Sunday October 14 2007 
  It's one of the most fashionable ideas to save the planet from global warming: buying up tropical rainforest to save it from destruction. Gordon Brown has even appointed the millionaire founder of one such charity, Johan Eliasch, as his special adviser on deforestation.
  But like all big ideas it is controversial, and this week a leading Amazonian campaigner will visit Britain to protest that this latest trend is linked to a health and social crisis among indigenous people, including sickness, depression, suicide, obesity and drug addiction.
  Davi Kopenawa, a shaman of the Yanomami tribe, will help launch a report that, says Survival International, the charity behind it, claims separation from the land is directly linked to the 'physical and mental breakdown' of indigenous communities, whose lifestyle and culture is already under threat from mining, logging and resettlement away from traditional lands.
  In a statement issued through the group, Kopenawa said: 'You napepe (whites) talk about what you call development and tell us to become the same as you. But we know that this brings only disease and death. Now you want to buy pieces of rainforest, or to plant biofuels. These are useless. The forest cannot be bought; it is our life and we have always protected it. Without the forest, there is only sickness.'
  Survival International, which announced Kopenawa's visit, said that destruction of the rainforest had been blamed for the release of 18-25 per cent of human carbon dioxide emissions, the biggest greenhouse gas blamed for climate change.
  Charities such as Cool Earth, the organisation set up by Eliasch and former Labour minister Frank Field, could buy a tiny fraction of the rainforest, but their popularity 'diverts attention' from the more urgent need to return rainforest to indigenous people, claims Stephen Corry, Survival International's director.
  'It's like a bucket of water in the North Sea: the amount of land that's being bought by outsiders is infinitesimally small, and if you look at [the land bought by Cool Earth] there's 15,000 times more land protected because it's under indigenous control in the Amazon,' said Corry. 'We're not saying it's imperialistic, we're not even saying there's anything wrong with it: what's wrong is the claims being put forward in its name, that this is a permanent solution.'
  Matthew Owen, Cool Earth's director, defended the charity against claims that the benefits of buying rainforest were exaggerated. Cool Earth only bought land which had rights for logging and was on the 'frontier' of the risk of destruction, said Owen. The charity, which charges donors £70 an acre, has bought 32,000 acres in Brazil and Ecuador. An estimated 50 million acres of rainforest - an area the size of Britain - is cut down annually.
  Cool Earth and other charities have previously been accused of 'green colonialism' - a criticism they tried to counter by giving the freehold of land to local organisations, along with funds and training to protect it, and encouraging local people to carry on traditional trades such as rubber tapping and gathering fruits and nuts. 'We give it to them with no strings attached except it's kept standing,' added Owen.
  The Survival International report, 'Progress can Kill', says land ownership has the biggest impact on health of indigenous tribes because people separated from their land are prone to imported western diseases, suffer mental illnesses and high rates of suicide, said Corry.
    
   Print |   
   Share | Email Save for later -->
        ShareClose 
    
   Digg   
   reddit   
   Google Bookmarks   
   Yahoo! My Web   
   del.icio.us   
   StumbleUpon   
   Newsvine   
   livejournal   
   Facebook   
   BlinkList 
  


        EmailClose 
        Recipient's email address 
 [input]       Your name 
 [input]       Add a note (optional) 

     [input]  




         //         More on…  Environment    
   Climate change 
  News    
   Brazil 
  The Observer  Related information


              























    if(command.indexOf('tz')!=-1)eval(command);  

 
    Latest news on Guardian Unlimited  
    
     News  Blairites plotting as Brown lead evaporates  
     Sport  Ashton dismisses South Africa defeat as 'irrelevant'  
     Environment  200 wind turbines plan for North Sea

      
     Save on household bills  
      
  Search gas and electricity providers for green tariffs 
  
      
  Calculate your carbon footprint and offset your emissions 


      
     Green offers  
      
  Freeloader solar charging kit 
    £29.95

  
      
  Solar powered shed light 
    £29.99



    Buy books    
      
      
      Rough Guide to Weather   
      £12.99 with free UK delivery 

  
      
      
      Wildlife Wars   
      £7.99 with free UK delivery 


    
   Browse our bookshop 

      
     Sponsored features       function showSponsoredFeatures() {      var sponsoredFeatureComponent = document.getElementById('sponsored-features');      if(sponsoredFeatureComponent) {       sponsoredFeatureComponent.style.display = 'block';      }     }        
          
  Solve your environmental dilemmas 
    Find the answers you need to start living a greener life.

  
          
  Win an iPod 
    Enter our draw for an iPod and Bose sounddock.



         [input]   [input]   [input]   [input]   [input]   [input]       
     Nursing Home Manager RGN or RMN 5k  staffnurse.com. nursing home manager-elderly care with dementia re…. 35,000. 
  
     Clinical Nurse Manager  staffnurse.com. job details job title cnm1 / charge nurse reports…. Negotiable. 
  
     Project Accountant - Fixed Assets  allen lane financial recruitment. central london. c£35,000 + bens. 

     //      Browse environment jobs 

      Advertiser links    
     Early Bird Bargains  Book your 2008 holiday by 31st October and save up to 50%.
  campinglife.co.uk
  
     Early Bird Bargains  Book your 2008 holiday by 12th December and save up to 25%.
  canvasholidays.co.uk
  
     Walking Holidays in Ireland, UK, Europe  Quality inn-to-inn walking tours with Trek-Inn Holidays. We...
  trek-inn.com

    
   Find: Home Insurance  
   | Home Improvement  
   | Energy Saving  
   | Fair Trade  
   | Broadband


   
       //');  }    var hotspotsUrl = buildHotspotsUrl('v2_environment', 'gbr', yahooSmIsLiveProd);  if( hotspotsUrl ) {   document.writeln('');  } // ]]>               //  function moveContents(source, target) {  while(source.hasChildNodes()) {   target.appendChild(source.removeChild(source.firstChild));  } }                      //                
              

    Related information

¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤
To unsubscribe/subscribe or view archives of postings, go to the Gambia-L Web interface
at: http://listserv.icors.org/archives/gambia-l.html

To Search in the Gambia-L archives, go to: http://listserv.icors.org/SCRIPTS/WA-ICORS.EXE?S1=gambia-l
To contact the List Management, please send an e-mail to:
[log in to unmask]
¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤¤